| # | Title | Vidder(s) | Song (if different) | Artist | Fandom(s) | Vidshows |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Because I'm Awesome | Anoel | The Dollyrots | Glee | ||
| 2 | I Honestly Love You | Anoel | Olivia Newton-John | Glee | ||
| 3 | I Love It | Anoel | Icona Pop | Glee | ||
| 4 | I Wanna Dance | jarrow | Glee | Glee | ||
| 5 | I'm Gonna Be... | Milly | Imma Stop Lovin' Drugs | Titus Jones (Ke$ha vs. Glee Cast vs. La Roux vs. The Black Eyed Peas vs. Iglu & Hartly) | Glee | |
| 6 | Just Another Girl | jarrow | The Killers | Glee | ||
| 7 | Make Your Own Kind of Music | Buffyann | original by Mama Cass, remix by Mathieu Bouthier and Muttonheads | Glee | ||
| 8 | Music Again | Anoel | Adam Lambert | Glee |